What’s the general relationship between arguments and narratives?
- RPLv 74 weeks ago
An argument presents opposing points of view whereas a narrative explains something, without taking a stand or attempting to define or defend a particular stance.
- PLv 74 weeks ago
A narrative is a manifesto along set lines or a fixed theme. It presents a case, possibly aspirational rather than facual, which is based upon particular beliefs.
An argument seeks to impose a pre-held view on others, or lead them to a conclusion which is in agreement.
A discussion follows the middle ground in accepting valid points presented from participants in order to reach a concensus
- ♜Ⓢⓚⓨ ❍ Ⓓⓞⓥⓔ ♜Lv 54 weeks ago
A narrative helps to consolidate facts and arguments into a superstructure. Such as the narrative of the Big Bang and of life evolving on Earth. There are perhaps a million facts of observation and many deductions along the way. In order to make sense of it we produce a narrative which approximates and extrapolates all these facts and deductions.
The point of inductive reasoning is not to guarantee the correct theory. It is to construct a world in which these facts and deductions could live.
It is not to replace direct experience but to integrate experience into a narrative which is in sync. This narrative is not a static being but a dynamical adaptive being. When we learn something new we must update our models and so the narrative.
It is simply a representation of how we see the world given all these facts and deductions. And I believe it makes us more intelligent because we can visualise the whole project with our mind’s eye.
I know these thing can be abused but used correctly can stimulate further research and reflection.
I believe there is a rigorous system in which induction has a solid position.
- Anonymous4 weeks ago
An argument will attempt to persuade you to a conclusion, a narrative will generally give a factual commentary without any great explanation.