Who's side on you on?
A little kid screamed to the top of his lungs right into an autistic man's ear in a restaurant and the autistic man punched the kid across the face so hard the kid went flying. and the man was arrested. who's side is right?
- Anonymous8 months ago
This is a tough one. But punching is worse than screaming
- sparrowLv 78 months ago
Obviously, the autistic guy was wrong, but he should get a light sentence considering
that loud noises are especially painful and disturbing for autistic people.
- 9 months ago
Peter Gore Seer,
Both Were Child Minded but The Boy Was Harmed. And A Child Screams Can Reach A Terrifying Frequency, That Can Hurt The Brain.
- 9 months ago
That’s a hard one. I think I’d sympathise with the Autistic man and the child. I’d wonder where the caretaker of the autistic man was and why the parents of the kid weren’t watching and teaching their kid to be more responsible. It’s not the Autistic man or the kid’s fault.
- What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
- busterwasmycatLv 79 months ago
Not on the side of the parents of the kid, or on the side of the autistic person's human associates either, and definitely not on the side of the law officials who thought it appropriate to arrest a mentally handicapped person for "excessively" responding to an assault. The least guilty party here would be the poor autistic person just minding his own business.
- SimplytheFACTSLv 79 months ago
if the autistic man can't control himself, he would be not guilty due to mental disease or defect and consequences would be based on that...could be placement in a supervised or more restrictive setting.
the big question would be where was his care taker if he can't control himself. The care taker is liable.
If he was thought to be not in need of a care taker, he is criminally liable and can be jailed.
- WillLv 79 months ago
Neither, but more on the kid's side. If the child were an adult that would be considered assault had it caused hearing loss in the victim. However the adult, autistic or not, intentionally struck the child with the intention of causing harm and therefore will be arrested and charged with assault/battery (depending on the state).
People with cognitive disabilities don't deserve any slack. Especially people with autism. They damn well know right from wrong. I know this first hand due to having worked with some and going to school with some. They know damn well what is right and wrong. And they are capable of learning when you are stern with them. They just can't analyze social behavior such as facial expressions, tones of the voice, when to shut up, etc..
- Anonymous9 months ago
Sounds like neither side was ready for a public outing, but punching is worse than screaming.
- BrianLv 79 months ago
Good. That brat should not been screaming;