Should I continue piano lessons?
I have been going for about three months, but I haven t progressed as fast as other players do.
When I first started I already knew how to read sheet music, dynamics, time signatures and all that other stuff (from playing the violin at school) but didn t know anything about the piano itself.
Other piano players have started playing songs like Fur Elise by week one but I am stuck playing the easy version of Aloha Oe.
Its not that I have a hard time learning, I learn pieces very fast and don t know what to practice because I have already mastered the songs and scales two days after our session.
Should I ask my teacher to speed up things or what? Piano lessons are very expensive for me.
- Anonymous1 year ago
Anyone can play something,
but can you REALLY play it?
I'm taking piano studio (I'm a vocalist, in voice studio).
The angle of my hands
the attack of the note
the motion of my wrist on the attack of the note
the balance of voices between my fingers
the balance of phrases and how they change dynamically
the appropriate use of rubato, pedal, etc
the 'emotional character' of the piece, and how well I express it.
The meaning of the piece
Harmonic analysis and other analysis of the piece
These are all more than just the notes. Anyone can learn to play the notes, 'mastering it' means your very aware of all of these things. Not just "Oh, well the answer to one of the things I've listed is x", all of the aforementioned should be very planned and laid out.
I can 'play' Mozart's Fantasia in D minor
but I'm working on pieces and PLAYING pieces with considerations from that list from Schumman's Album for the Young (for children). I get to sing with a symphony in December as a 'guest artist' and I'm not bothered by it, but oh my god I played at my first piano recital and I almost fainted.
(next semester I get a Bach prelude and 2 Chopin preludes, also the very easy kind).
- Anonymous1 year ago
yes i think that its ok to tell your teacher give you harder materials
- zenoLv 71 year ago
Stop taking lessons and listen to the music
Of previous piano players like Ray Charles,
Fats domino, billy Joel, the carpenters, and
Many other brilliant musicians. Play the songs
You like and that resonate with you. Billy Joel
Was self taught and played what sounded right
To him. Part of music is listening to your instincts and make your own style that defines
You. So what songs do you want to be part
Of or have represent your work? I hope it's
As good as the carpenters or billy Joel. They
Were great. Good luck
- Candid ChrisLv 71 year ago
The piano is a different set of strings than a violin and it has foot controls so ask your teacher to watch you play for a few minutes even if you need to pay a little more for the 'private session' part.
- What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
- MamiankaLv 71 year ago
My husband and I are both career musicians and music teachers. He is a fine pianist who has been a soloist at Lincoln Center. NOBODY is playing Fur Elise after their first lesson - unless they barely started it from some bogus YooToob "follow my fingers" site. Perhaps other students are better at practicing than you are. Perhaps they takes notes at lessons, and follow the teachers directions and advice. So first you are complaining - and then tell us that you *mastered* the works assigned in 2 days. If you play them for your teacher, they must not think that YOUR idea of mastery is not the same as theirs - and that you are not as proficient as you claim. Talk to them about it - and see why YOU think you are being held back.
- KathyLv 71 year ago
Keep trying, because not all people learn to play the piano at the same pace.
- 1 year ago
Islam does not allow Western stuff