Eli Manning or Philip Rivers?

Who would you rather have? I asked this question a year ago, and the unanimous answer was Philip Rivers. A couple of answers said that the trade was horrible, and if the Giants kept Rivers, they woud've won 3 more super bowls. I'm interestd to see what people say now. BQ: Is Tom Coughlin a Hall of Famer? show more Who would you rather have?

I asked this question a year ago, and the unanimous answer was Philip Rivers. A couple of answers said that the trade was horrible, and if the Giants kept Rivers, they woud've won 3 more super bowls. I'm interestd to see what people say now.

BQ: Is Tom Coughlin a Hall of Famer?
Update: This was the question I asked a week after the Miracle at the New Meadowlands:
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20101227130206AA32WIN
Update 2: Hooray! I sparked an argument!!
19 answers 19