Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Entertainment & MusicMovies · 8 years ago

How did Sherlock Holmes survive falling over the Reichenbach falls in A Game of Shadows?

Is there any explanation for how he would have managed that, or just are we ignoring the dangers. Involved. I mean isn't falling. And hitting water just like hitting rock? What about hypothermia?

12 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Okay, first off, to answer the question of how he would have survived, we need to consider what are the leading possible causes of mortality in falls from waterfalls.

    First: the freezing cold water. Though the temperature shock can cause cardiac arrest on impact, this is not an enormous concern for someone who is fairly young and without an underlying heart condition. Since (as per the dates on the gravestone) Holmes was 37, and certainly someone who led an active lifestyle, we can safely assume his heart could indeed take the strain.

    The other and more prevalent danger is the human Cold-Shock Reflex, which causes hyperventilation (and immediate gasping of course) in response to the temperature change.

    Gasping in water is the obvious danger. Hyperventilation is the more insidious one, robbing the body of oxygen that it desperately needs, and causing exhaustion quickly.

    In any case. Cold-shock reflex is the number one killer out there for any kind of plunge into cold water, but is entirely preventable so long as one remembers to suppress the reflex. Not easy but perfectly feasible, so long as you're not too busy panicking. Holmes definitely wasn't.

    Of course we've all heard of hypothermia, but it does not set in as quickly as might be imagined. The US Marine Corps gives about 15 minutes for hypothermia to set in, on average, in freezing water, and though with an already serious injury, Holmes would not have been on the high end of that scale, again, getting out of the water in that time is possible.

    Second: Post-impact conditions.

    Unlike when one hits standing water from a great height (which is about as bad as hitting concrete) water near the base of a waterfall is thoroughly whipped with air and so provides a comparatively soft landing. The good news is that one does not get killed by the impact with the surface. The bad news is that it is impossible to float (and near impossible to swim) in this kind of water, and once submerged, even in the presence of daylight it is pitch-black because of the light blocking properties of the microscopic air bubbles. Adding to this the fact that the currents -and the impact- rob a person of any sense of direction, it is usually impossible to break surface before drowning, and worse, attempting to do so either does nothing measurable, or brings a swimmer back into danger as the surface currents tend to flow towards the falls.

    If a person however knows their physics (Holmes did), can stay calm long enough to regain orientation (he did have a pretty cool head after all), can manage not to drown while attempting to do so (hence the usefulness of the oxygen device), then it is possible to get carried away from the waterfall by swimming diagonally DOWNWARD and away from the fall, where eventually one hits a deeper (and always outbound) current.

    Third: Impact.

    Okay, so now we know that the impact with the frothy water is not so bad, but what about rocks?

    The greatest danger is right beneath the falls (because of rocks that get washed over and go straight down) and if anyone noticed, when Holmes did break away from Moriarty, he used the momentum to push away from the base of the falls. Pure luck? Possibly. More likely, though his eyes were closed, he was probably keeping track of their relative positions thought orientational perception, and broke away at the optimal time to get out from right under the falls, but not far enough to hit water that would have had too little air to allow for a shot at surviving the surface impact.

    So, in summary, Holmes avoided the largest danger of hitting rock, used the oxygen device to breathe underwater until he could regain his bearings, and then probably swam for a current that he could ride away from the falls, and finally surfaced, then exited the water and found some kind of shelter before freezing to death, or was found downstream.

    It is possible that he used the device just before impact (so that when the cold-shock reflex was triggered, he would not have drowned), but unlikely, since the risk of losing it would have been far too great.

    More likely, he took a deep breath before impact, held it, suppressing the initial gasping phase of the cold shock reflex, and then used the device underwater.

    Easy to survive? Hell no!

    Possible, yes, especially if you got a mind like Sherlock Holmes did which never ever shuts down, and nerves of steel.

    Source(s): Mostly my dad, a former SERE trainer for the US armed forces and now teaching whitewater rafting safety classes in Washington (esp for the Boulder Drop), and ice-fishing in Alaska. Also, the following websites have some fairly good info: beyondcoldwaterbootcamp.com/en/4-phases-of-cold-water-immersion stevenahill.com/2010/08/survive-a-waterfall/
  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    With every day pass, our country is getting into more and more trouble. The inflation, unemployment and falling value of dollar are the main concern for our Government but authorities are just sleeping, they don’t want to face the fact. Media is also involve in it, they are force to stop showing the real economic situation to the people. I start getting more concern about my future as well as my family after watching the response of our Government for the people that affected by hurricane Katrina.

    According to recent studies made by World Bank, the coming crisis will be far worse than initially predicted. So if you're already preparing for the crisis (or haven't started yet) make sure you watch this video at http://www.familysurvival.tv and discover the 4 BIG issues you'll have to deal with when the crisis hits, and how to solve them fast (before the disaster strikes your town!) without spending $1,000s on overrated items and useless survival books.

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    It could be that what we saw at the end of the movie isn't really what happened but only what Watson saw. In the Sherlock Holmes television series starring Jeremy Brett there was an extremely similar scene. Holmes and Moriarti went over the falls and both seemingly died, but that was only through Watson's eyes, only Moriarti went over in reality.

    The other possibility is that Holmes fell into the water at an angle that wouldn't break his back and he was able to breathe using Microft's device and swim to shore.

  • 8 years ago

    As for surviving underwater he took Mycroft's breathing device. But if you mean the impact of the fall itself then read this portion I copied from the film's trivia page on IMDB (A person falling onto water from a great height would be killed by the impact, so an oxygen supply would be of no benefit. It would be equivalent to falling on concrete. However water at the base of a waterfall is highly aerated and therefore softer. (Divers practicing from high platforms often use aerated water in case of errors). It is possible to survive a fall into the base of a waterfall.)

  • What do you think of the answers? You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer.
  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    Well there are alot more unbelievable stunts and scenes in movies, so you have to just accept that its a movie, in reality he would have died infact his spine and leg bones would probably have been reduced to ashes im going to judge that waterfall was like 300 feet at least, and if he did survive the fall he would drown because his spine and legs would definitely be broken.

    But it is a movie and movies most of the time arent very realistic thats why they are movies

  • 8 years ago

    First of all he fell into water so the damages is a lot less, and some studies have found out that if when you're falling you Completely relax your body, you won't die from the fall. And when Sherlock Holmes was falling, if you pay attention, he closed his eyes.

  • 8 years ago

    Well he did survive having a giant fishhook trough his arm... I think Hollywood often stretches the human capabilities but for all we know, the water may have been really deep and sort of warm? Haha I don't know- good point. He did have the little oxygen tank though :)

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    well this is a movie where everything is fiction. the point of movies is to seem real just like Red when Bruce Willis stepped out of a moving car on foot and the tail end missed him by a hair

  • Anonymous
    3 years ago

    That is a good observation

  • 8 years ago

    He had that breathing device and its just a movie

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.